Bull. Natl. Mus. Nat. Sci., Ser. B, 33(3 · 4), pp. 133–136, December 21, 2007
Chromosome Numbers of Zannichellia L. (Zannichelliaceae) in Japan
Norio Tanaka1, Yu Ito2, Ruriko Matsuyama3 and Koichi Uehara3
1
Tsukuba Botanical Garden, National Museum of Nature and Science,
Amakubo 4–1–1, Tsukuba, 305–0005, Japan
E-mail: ntanaka@kahaku.go.jp
2
Botanical Gardens, Koishikawa, Graduate School of Science, The University of Tokyo,
Hakusan 3–7–1, 112–0001, Japan
3
Faculty of Horticulture, Chiba University, Matsudo 641, Matsudo, 271–8510, Japan
Abstract Chromosome numbers of Zannichellia L. (Zannichelliaceae) found in Japan was studied. Plants collected from six localities had a chromosome number of 2n⫽24. The chromosome
numbers of Zannichellia found in Japan were firstly reported with collecting information. According to existing taxonomic keys, Zannichellia plants used in this study were determined to be Z.
palustris or Z. pedunculata, a species previously not reported in Japan.
Key words : Chromosome number, flow cytometry, Japan, Zannichellia palustris, Zannichellia
pedunculata.
Introduction
Zannichellia L. (Zannichelliaceae) is a genus
of annual or perennial submerged aquatic plants,
which inhabit brackish and fresh waters. It is
widely distributed in tropical and temperate latitudes (Tomlinson, 1982). The taxonomy of Zannichellia has not been studied entirely and has
been confused not only in Japan but throughout
the world (Cook, 1996; Kadono, 1994). Japanese
Zannichellia plants have been identified as Z.
palustris L. (Ohwi, 1972; Yamashita, 1982;
Kadono, 1994).
The chromosome numbers of Zannichellia
have been previously reported as 2n⫽12, 14, 24,
28, 32, 34, and 36 (Van Vierssen, 1982; Talavera
et al., 1986; Talavera and Garcia Murillo, 1992;
Montgomery et al., 1997; Mesicek and Javurkova-Jarolimova, 1992). Zannichellia palustris was
also found to have variations as follows: 2n⫽24
from Europe, China and Japan; 28 from Europe;
34 from Europe and China; 36 from Europe
(Scheerer, 1940; Tarnavschi, 1948; Harada, 1956;
Reese, 1961, 1963, 1967; Hedberg and Hedberg,
1964; van Vierssen, 1982; van Vierssen and van
Wijk, 1982; Uotila et al., 1983; Mesicek and
Javurkova-Jarolimova, 1992; Sun, 1992; Montgomery et al., 1997).
Harada (1956) reported 2n⫽24 as the chromosome number of Z. palustris in Japan. However,
the collecting site and voucher specimens are not
documented. Therefore, observation of chromosome numbers from locations with collection
data is necessary to provide basic information in
order to revise the taxonomic treatment. In this
paper, we report chromosome numbers of Z.
palustris from six localities in Japan.
Materials and Methods
Six of the eleven localities of Zannichellia
plants reported by Tanaka et al. (2006) were used
in this study (Table 1). Some individuals from
each location were studied. Voucher specimens
are deposited in the National Museum of Nature
and Science (TNS).
Root tips of each plant were cut and soaked in
8 mM aqueous hydroxyquinoline solution at 4°C
overnight. After fixation with a 3 : 1 (v/v) mixture
of ethanol and acetic acid at room temperature
for three hours, they were macerated in 1 N HCl
for 10 min at 60°C, stained with 1% aceto-orcein
134
Norio Tanaka et al.
Table 1. Localities and voucher specimens of populations investigated in japan.
Population
Locality
Voucher
Tofutsu
Yudo
Takahoko
Ogawara
Nishiki-Hama
Nobeoka
Lake Tofutsu, Koshimizu, Hokkaido Pref.
Lake Yudo, Toyokoro, Hokkaido Pref.
Lake Takahoko, Rokkasyo, Aomori Pref.
Lake Ogawara, Kamikita, Aomori Pref.
Nishiki-Hama, Higashi-Izumo, Shimane Pref.
Nobeoka, Miyazaki Pref.
TNS 9528810-9528818
TNS 9528819, 9528820
TNS 9528835, 9528836
TNS 9528778
TNS 9528826-9528831
TNS 9528833, 9528834
Fig. 1. Somatic chromosomes of Zannichellia at metaphase. A: Tofutsu, B: Takahoko, C: Ogawara. Bar indicates 5 m m.
for 1 min at room temperature, and squashed on a
glass slide.
Flow cytometry (FCM) analyses were conducted to indirectly estimate the chromosome
number of Zannichellia plants whose roots could
not be collected. Samples were prepared using
CyStain UV precise P kit (Partec, Germany) for
nuclei extraction and staining of nuclear DNA.
The genome size was determined by a basic procedure of Ploidy Analyzer PA (Partec, Germany).
Oryza sativa L. cv. Nihonbare was used as an internal standard.
Results and Discussion
The chromosome numbers of Zannichellia
plants from Tofutsu, Takahoko, and Ogawara
were 2n⫽24 by microscopic observation (Fig. 1).
By FCM analyses, the genome size of the plants
in Yudo, Takahoko, Nishiki–Hama and Nobeoka,
were shown to be nearly equal to each other (Fig.
2, Table 2). Although the peak indices of each
samples had minor differences (1.209–1.241,
Table 2), these samples were estimated to be
2n⫽24 on the presumption that their chromosome numbers are an even number. These results
Table 2.
Peak indices of flow cytometry analyses.
Peak index*
Population
Yudo
Takahoko
Nishiki-Hama
Nobeoka
1
2
3
1.239
1.241
1.209
1.221
2.489
2.499
2.408
2.388
—
—
4.855
—
*Peak index shows the relative location when the peak
of internal standard is assumed to be 1.0.
showed that the Zannichellia plants from all localities of this study have a chromosome number
of 2n⫽24. This is consistent with the only data
on chromosome numbers of Japanese Zannichellia (Harada, 1956).
Some Zannichellia in this study were not determined to be Z. palustris, which is the only
known Zannichellia species in Japan (Ohwi
1972; Yamashita, 1982; Kadono, 1994). According to Talavera et al. (1986), who used features
of leaf and fruit as key characters, plants of Tohfutsu, Yudo and Ogawara were determined to be
Z. palustris L., while Takahoko, Nishiki-Hama,
and Nobeoka, had intermediate characters between Z. palustris and Z. pedunculata Reichenb.
Chromosome numbers of Zannichellia
135
Fig. 2. Peaks in fluorescence of Zannichellia plants of Takahoko (Peak 2 and 3), from analyses with flow cytometer. The horizontal scale indicates fluorescent intensity (calibrated by the internal standard, Oryza sativa:
Peak 1) and the vertical scale indicates number of cells.
(not previously reported in Japan). According to
van Vierssen (1982), who used leaf and fruit as
key characters, Takahoko, Nishiki-Hama and
Nobeoka, were identified as Z. pedunculata.
However, this study described the chromosome
numbers of Z. palustris and Z. pedunculata to be
2n⫽24 and 2n⫽36, respectively. Van Vierssen’s
taxonomic description of morphological characters and chromosome numbers are inconsistent
with our results. In the future, a molecular phylogenetic approach would be necessary to identify
and delineate taxa in this genus.
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to Satoru Kinoshita, Tadashi
Minamidani and Heigoro Narusako, Takatomo
Yano, Masahiko Takiguchi, Takashi Mori,
Koubei Hosoi, Mami Yamazaki, Hidenobu Kunii,
Kaname Kamiya, Satoru Araki for collecting
plants; Masahiro Mii and Chin Don Poh for giving us the use of ploidy analyzer. This study was
supported by a Grant-in-Aid from the Ministry of
Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology, Japan (No. 17710194).
References
Cook, C. D. K. 1996. Aquatic Plant Book. 228 pp. SPB
Academic Publishing, Amsterdam.
Environment Agency of Japan (ed.). 2000. Threatened
Wildlife of Japan-Red Data Book 2nd ed.–vol. 8, Vascular Plants. 664 pp. Japan Wildlife Research Center,
Tokyo. (In Japanese).
Harada, I. 1956. Cytological studies in Helobiae, 1. Chromosome idiograms and a list of chromosome numbers
in seven families. Cytologia 21: 306–328.
Hedberg, I and Hedberg, O. 1964. Documented chromosome numbers of Swedish Plants. Svensk Botanisk Tidskrift 58(1):125–128.
Kadono, Y. 1994. Aquatic Plants of Japan. 179 pp. Bunichi Sogo Shuppan, Co. Ltd, Tokyo (in Japanese).
Mesicek, J. and Javurkova-Jarolimova, V. 1992. List of
Chromosome Numbers of the Czech Vascular Plants.
49 pp. Academia, Praha.
Montgomery, L., Khalaf, M. Baailey, J. P. and Gornal, K.
J. 1997. Contributions to a cytological catalogue of the
British and Irish flora, 5. Watsonia 21: 365–368.
Ohwi, J. 1972. Flora of Japan. 1560 pp. Shibundo, Tokyo
(in Japanese).
Reese, G. 1961. Chromosome numbers of Central and
Northwest European plant species. Opera Botaica 5: 1–
581.
Reese, G. 1963. Uber die deutschen Ruppia-und Zannichellia-Kategorien und ihre Verbreitung in
Schleswig-Holstein. Schriften des Naturwissenchaften
Vereins für Shleswig-Holstein 34: 44–70.
Reese, G. 1967. Cytologische und taxonomische Untersuchungen an Zannichellia palustris L. Biolologisches
Zentralblatt 86: 277–306.
Scheerer, H. 1940. Chromosomenzahalen aus der
Schreswig-Hols-Teinischen Flora II. Planta 32:
716–725.
Sun, X.-Z. 1992. Flora Reipublicae Popularis Sinicae
136
Norio Tanaka et al.
Tomus 8. 218 pp. Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese).
Talavera, S., Garcia Murillo, P. and Smit, H. 1986. Sobre
el genero Zannichellia L. (Zannichelliaceae). Lagascalia 14 (2): 241–271.
Talavera, S. and Garcia Murillo, P. 1992. Numeros cromosomaricos de plantas occidentals, 661–667. Anales del
Jardin Botanicode Madrid 50: 83.
Tanaka, N., Ito, Y. and Uehara, K. 2006. Distribution and
new localities of Zannichellia palustris L. (Zannichelliaceae) in Japan. Annals of Tsukuba Botanical Garden
25: 1–6.
Tarnavschi, I. T. 1948. Die chromosomenzahlen der Anthophyten-Flora Von Rumänien mit einen Ausblick auf
das Polyploide-Problem. Bululetinul Gradinii Botanice
si al Muszeulvi Botanic de la Universitatea 28: 1–130.
Tomlinson, P. B. 1982. Anatomy of the Monocotyledons
VII. Helobiae (Alismatidae). Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Uotila, P., van Vierssen, W. and van Wijk, R. J. 1983.
Notes on the morphology and taxonomy of Zannichellia in Turky. Annales Bototanici Fennici 20: 351–356.
Van Vierssen, W., 1982. The ecology of communities
dominated by Zannichellia taxa in western Europe. I.
Characterization and autecology of the Zannichellia
taxa. Aquatic Botany 12: 103–155.
Van Vierssen, W. and van Wijk, R. J. 1982. On the identity of Zannichellia peltata Bertol. in western Europe. In:
van Vierssen, W. (ed.), The Ecology of Communities
Dominated by Zannichellia Taxa in Western Europe.
pp. 199–215. Stichting Studentenpers, Nijmegen.
Yamashita, T. 1982. Zannichelliaceae. In: Satake, Y.,
Ohwi, J., Kitamura, S., Watari, S. and Tominari, T.
(eds.), Wild Flowers of Japan I. Herbaceous Plants Monocotyledoneae. Heibonsha Ltd., Tokyo (in Japanese).