Pol. J. Environ. Stud. Vol. 32, No. 1 (2023), 833-841
ONLINE PUBLICATION DATE: 2022-12-05
DOI: 10.15244/pjoes/152725
Original Research
Discovering the Rare Tolypella intricata
(Trentepohl ex Roth) Leonh. 1863 (Charales,
Charophyceae) in Poland
Jacek Urbaniak1*, Rafał Krawczyk2
Department of Botany and Plant Ecology, Wrocław University of Environmental and Life Sciences,
pl. Grunwadzki 24a, 50-363Wrocław, Poland
2
Institute of Biological Sciences, Maria Curie-Skłodowska University, Akademicka 19, 20-033 Lublin, Poland
1
Received: 25 June 2022
Accepted: 10 August 2022
Abstract
Tolypella intricata is one of the rarest charophytes from the genus Tolypella that can be found both
in Poland and in Europe. Rarely found in the last 200 years, it was recently rediscovered in two localities
in eastern Poland in the Lublin region. In this article, we present two new locations of T. intricata
in Poland that make is a significant contribution to a closer understanding of the distribution of the biology
and ecology of this species. The article provides basic information on the autecology of T. intricata
together with the associated macrophyte vegetation. The morphology and ecology data are compared
with the literature, along with a critical review of such information found in the literature. The results
of molecular tests confirming the new position of T. intricata are also presented.
Keywords: biogeography, charophyta, distribution, ecology, Tolypella intricata, Poland
Introduction
In general, genus Tolypella (A.Braun), belonging
to the class Charophyceae (order Charales, family
Characeae), is one of the rarest genera in the whole
class. Currently, 21 species are accepted taxonomically
in the genus under the Tolypella species name [1]. Of
this genus, species Tolypella intricata (Trentepohl
ex Roth) Leonh. 1863 seems to be one of the rarest
charophytes species in Europe and worldwide [2]. It was
first discovered and collected probably in the vicinity of
Berlin and Leipzig (Eastern Germany). The available
*e-mail: jacek.urbaniak@upwr.edu.pl
information allows us to state that until the end of the
20th century, only a few sites where T. intricata was
recorded were known. All currently known information
on the distribution of T. intricata is provided in Table 1
and Fig. 1.
So far, there are no more recent data on the
prevalence of T. intricata in Europe. Certainly,
T. intricata is an extremally rare species that is not easy
to find, and this is one reason why no new localities of
this specimen have been identified. This study aims to
report the two new records of T. intricata in Eastern
Poland located in the Lublin Region. The discovered
populations of T. intricata are described in detail and
compared with literature data. This new finding of
T. intricata is discussed as a significant contribution to
the knowledge on this species biogeography.
834
Urbaniak J., Krawczyk R.
Materials and Methods
All data presented in Table 1 on the known locations
of T. intricata were collected from information obtained
using queries of herbarium collections (C, GB, GLM,
H, JE, KRA, L, LD, NY (C.V. Starr Virtual Herbarium),
POZ, WRSL, WAW) and literature data. Acronyms of
herbaria are given after NYBG Index Herbariorum [3]
Algae scientific names are given after AlgaeBase [1] and
IPNI [4] The abbreviated author names for plant names
are given as in IPNI [4] following recommendations
of ICN [5]. Below, we describe the two more recently
found localities of T. intricata in Poland. The species
was found by accident during many years of monitoring
research in the area of over a dozen or so kilometers
along the Vistula River. In further studies, no other
localitites of T. intricata occurrence were found. In
the case of the specimen collected near Witkowice,
molecular DNA analyses were performed to confirm
the discovery of T. intricata. The algae from the locality
near Witkowice was grown in artificial conditions
(greenhouses) in 2019 from soil samples (diaspors)
collected in early spring 2018. We have also used
determination keys [6, 7] to confirm both findings.
Table 1. Summary of all information known so far on the occurrence of T. intricata in Europe
Locality
Herbarium code, References
Belgium
1) East Flanders: Antwerp
NY
Denmark
1) Sydsjylland
C, NY, Olsen [35]
France
1) Centre-Val de Loire, Loir-et-Cher: Romorantin
2) Nouvelle-Aquitaine, Gironde: Bordeaux
3) Pays de la Loire, Sarthe: Le Chevain near Alençon, Sarthe Précigné
Germany
1) NSG Bislicher Inseln
2) Brandenburg: Berlin, Schöneberg, Falkensee, Trebbin b. Berlin, Neuruppin
vor Kränzlin
3) Baden-Württemberg: Karlsruhe (Brechtsee)
5) Saxen: Bienitz bei Leipzig
6) Niederlausitz: Golßen
6) Nordrhein-Westfalen: Krefeld
NY, Corillion [36]
NY
NY
NY
U.Abts (private collection)
NY
NY, Weyer [29]
NY
NY
NY
Grece
1) Attica
NY
Hungary
1) Budapest-Rákosfalva
NY
Ireland
1) close to Dublin
Moore [37]
Italy
1) Gargano
2) Lombardia
3) Veneto
4) Emilia-Romagna
WRSL
Bazzichelli and Abdelahad [38]
Bazzichelli and Abdelahad [38]
Bazzichelli and Abdelahad [38]
Netherland
various localities
Briunsma et al. [39]
Poland
1) Warmia: Carlshof bei Altfelde
2) Wielkopolska: Valley of Warta River (Wielkopolska region)
(C, GLM, H, LD, POZ, NY, W)
Gąbka [40]
Spain
1) Castilla - La Mancha: Cuenca, Torca del Agua
NY
Sweden
1) Gotland:Hangvar, Lerdala, Slite,Visby,
2) Øland
3) Skåne: Alnarp, Christianstad Lund, Trelleborg, Uppsala,
NY
[41]
NY
Serbia
1) Valjevac and Pačja
2) Zasavica
[42]
[43]
Discovering the Rare Tolypella intricata...
835
Table 1. Continued.
United Kindgom
1) England, Cambridgeshire: Harston, Welches Downs, The Wash below Mepal,
Sutton
2) England, Yorkshire: Goole
3) England, Bedfordshire: Brammingham near Luton
4) England, Surrey: Egham
5) England: Shortwood Common near Staines
6) England: Gloucestershire
NY, [37]
NY
NY
NY
NY
NY
[44]
Fig. 1. Distribution of T. intricata in Europe - drawing based on Table 1 and contained therein references and data from Herbaria
collection. Black dot - historical records<1945, white dot – record found near Karlsruhe, Germany at 2003 (NY), stars - recently found
records (this paper).
Phylogenetic Research
The genomic DNA was isolated using the DNeasy
Plant Mini Kit (Qiagen; Hilden Germany), according
to the manufacturer’s protocol using Mixer Mill
MM400 (Retsch; Haan, Germany) for plant tissue
disruption. We have used psbC chloroplast DNA region
that is used for phylogenetic studies in plants at all
taxonomic levels that allowed confirmation of the newly
sequenced cpDNA fragment from collected T. intricata,
with present data available at NCBI (Gene Bank).
The used region: psbC is often considered evolutionary
conservative but employed in phylogeny and taxonomy,
and some studies have found intraspecific variation in
this biogeographically informative gene regions that
has been contradicted [7]. PCR reaction mix included
(in the total volume of 20 µl): 1U Taq recombinant
polymerase (Thermo-Fisher Scientific), 10X Taq Buffer,
1 mM MgCl2, 0.5 µM of each primer, 0.4 mM dNTP
and 1 µl DNA template. PCR cycle was performed with
a Veriti Thermal Cycler (Life Technologies, Carlsbad,
CA, USA) with the following parameters: 8 min at
95ºC, followed by 30 cycles of 45 s at 95ºC, 45 s at
annealing temperature (51.2ºC) and 1min at 72ºC,
followed by a final extension step of 10 min at 72ºC.
Prior to sequencing, PCR products were purified using
GeneMATRIX PCR/ DNA Clean Up Purification Kit
(Eurx, Gdańsk, Poland). Sequencing, post-reaction
purification and reading were done by Genomed
(Warsaw, Poland) using an ABI 377XL Automated
DNA Sequencer (Applied Biosystems, Carlsbad,
CA, USA). All sequences are available in GenBank
(accession numbers: SP114263-SP114265). All molecular
analyses has been done at Department of Botany
836
Urbaniak J., Krawczyk R.
and Plant Ecology Wrocław University of Environmental
and Life Sciences). The obtained psbC sequences were
aligned using DNA Baser Sequence Assembler v4
[8] and checked for nucleotide variation using Mega
11 software [9]. The cpDNA sequences were aligned
using Muscle software implemented into Mega 11
[9, 10] before the phylogenetic analyses. We performed
maximum likelihood (ML) to infer the phylogenetic
relationships among selected individuals of Charophyte
nucleotide collected from NCBI. Bootstraps analyses
are based on 1000 replications of full heuristic searches.
The results based on the new data and data collected
from GeneBank are presented in Table 2.
Results and Discussion
Collection
The new localities of T. intricata were located at:
(1) a small river lake close to the Vistula river near
the village Witkowice (Figs 2-3), near Stalowa Wola
Table 2. Voucher details and GenBank psbC gene accession numbers of taxa used in this study. An-dash (-) indicates unavailable
information; new sequences are written bold.
Taxa
Isolate, Voucher
Locality
psbC gene NCBI accession number
Chara foliosa
KGK0233, Proctor138
-
MG880182.1
Chara foliosa
KGK0333, NY02146579
-
MG880181.1
Chara foliosa
KGK0341, NY00739274
-
MG880178.1
Chara globularis
KGK1574, NY02282230
-
KX430968.1
Chara tomentosa
-,-
-
KJ395866.1
Lamprothamnium heraldii
KGK0069, -
-
KJ395867.1
Lamprothamnium macropogon
-,-
-
KJ395868.1
Lychnothamnus barbatus
KGK4840, NY02020578
Lithuania
MF166879.1
Lychnothamnus barbatus
KGK3082, NY02146274
-
MF166876.1
Nitella axiliaris
KGK2327, NY00739255
-
KX430974.1
Nitella flexilis
KGK1769, NY02137614
-
KX430978.1
Nitella hyalina
KGK0190, NY02282228
-
KX430979.1
Nitella hyalina
KGK0059b, -
-
KJ395873.1
Nitella opaca
F146, -
-
KJ395876.1
Nitellopsis obtusa
KGK2013, NY02146765
-
KX430980.1
Nitellopsis obtusa
F131B, -
USA
KJ395878.1
Tolypella canadensis
WP0270, NY02026386
USA
KJ395828.1
Tolypella glomerata
WP0168, NY01475172
USA
KJ395848.1
Tolypella glomerata
WP0273, NY02026388
Canada
KJ395841.1
Tolypella glomerata
WP0263, NY02026383
Canada
KJ395840.1
Tolypella glomerata
WP0285, NY01003601
USA
KJ395831.1
Tolypella intricata
WP0147, NY01475169
-
KX430983.1
Tolypella intricata
WP0040, NY01475199
USA
KJ395844.1
Tolypella intricata
WP0058, NY01474971
USA
KJ395842.1
Tolypella intricata
WP0073, NY01474970
USA
KJ395829.1
Tolypella intricata
JB1477, - this paper
Poland
SP114263.1
Tolypella intricata
JB1478, - this paper
Poland
SP114264.1
Tolypella intricata
JB1479, - this paper
Poland
SP114265.1
Tolypella prolifera
WP0260, NY02026384
USA
KJ395856.1
Tolypella prolifera
WP0060, NY01003496
Canada
KJ395843.1
Discovering the Rare Tolypella intricata...
Fig. 2. Occurrence of T. intricata near Witkowice.
Fig. 3. Small river lake close to Vistula river near village
Witkowice where T.intricata was found.
(Central Poland, Nadwiślańska Valley, Sandomierska
Basin), 50°45′38″N, 21°50′46″E, 08-06-2009. T. intricata
was collected using grapnels, then dried and stored
in the collection of dry specimens in the Department
of Botany and Plant Ecology Wrocław University of
Environmental Sciences.
(2) a temporary pond among arable fields near
Kotlice village (Figs 4-5), near Hrubieszów (Kotlina
Hrubieszowska, Wyżyna Wołyńska), 50°40′54″N,
23°35′28″E. T. intricata was grown in artificial
conditions (greenhouses) in 2019 from soil samples
(diaspors) collected in early spring 2018.
Description of T. intricata Specimens from
the Two New Localities Found in Poland
Both newly found specimens of T. intricata were
medium-size, 25-40 cm-high plants, branched with
plant main axis 1.0-1.5 mm in diameter. Plants were
greyish green and moderately to heavily encrusted
(Witkowice, Figs 6-8).
837
Fig. 4. Occurrence of T. intricata near Kotlice.
Fig. 5. Small temporary pond among arable fields near Kotlice
village.
The internodes were up to three times as long as
the branches. We have observed 7-8 fertile branchlets
in a whorl in very dense heads, divided once or twice
with nodes bearing 3-6 lateral rays. Secondary rays
with 1-2 nodes bore 5-7 celled tertiary rays. The end
segment was 3-4 cells, with the last cell conical up
to acute. About 7-8 sterile branchlets in a whorl were
long, simple, and divided once or twice with one node
bearing 2-3 lateral rays. The end cell was conical to
acute. Lateral rays were elongated, composed of 4-6
cells with the end cell conical and acute. Dense heads
consisted of two or more reduced fertile whorls on
the upper shortened part of branch axes. All studied
T. intricata specimens were monoecious plants with
gametangia at fertile branchlet nodes at the base of
fertile branchlets. Oogonia were numerous, aggregate,
2-4 at a node, 385-460 μm long, 280-465 μm wide.
Oospores were dark brown 305-360 μm long and
220-360 μm wide. Antheridia were generally solitary
and were about 310-360 μm in diameter (data are based
on measurements of approximately 15-20 oospores and
5-7 antheridia).
838
Urbaniak J., Krawczyk R.
Phylogenetic Analyses
Fig. 6. General appearance with reduced fertile whorls of
T. intricata.
As similar as in case phylogenetic analysis
presented prevoiusly [11, 12] genus Tolypella was
monophyletic in performed analysis and both sections:
sect. Tolypella to which belong T. glomerata, as well
as sect. Rothia (T. intricata, T. prolifera, T. canadensis)
were strongly supported in the ML bootstrap analysis
(Fig. 9). Additionally, in a sect. Rothia all studied
sequences that origin from two species T. intricata and
T. prolifera formed two separate clades with strong
bootstrap support. One of them contained seven
individuals consisted of sequences that come from
T. intricata (three newly sequenced and four other
collected from NBCI), whereas second was formed
by two specimens of T. prolifera. Single sequence of
T. canadensis formed a sister clade to them, but weaker
supported. Species from the genus Nitella (inside tribe
Nitellae) were paraphyletic to Tolypella and as similar
as in results obtained by [13, 14] was a sister clade to
Chareae (Chara, Lamprothamnium, Lychnothamnus
and Nitellopisis).
In general, the newly collected in Poland sequences
from T. intricata samples together with samples from
NCBI was separated from T. prolifera. Both species
formed monophyletic clades strongly supported by
bootstrap analyses ≥99 (Fig. 9).
Notices about the Occurrence of T. intricata
Fig. 7. Branchlets fertile in a whorl in dense heads of T. intricata.
Fig. 8. Fertile branchlets with oogonia and visible end segment
with the last cell conical, acute of T. intricata.
It seems that T. intricata in SE Poland can be
found in two types of habitats. The first type near the
town of Witkowice is small river lakes formed on the
active floodplain of a large river, such as the Vistula or
the Warta rivers. These are astatic ponds periodically
drying out partially or completely. The substrate
is dominated by a fine-grained mineral fraction.
The aquatic vegetation in such reservoirs is poorly
developed and not very rich in species; the species
found are often pioneering species. The following
species of vascular plants include Potamogeton
trichoides Cham. & Schltdl., Ceratophyllum demersum
L., Elodea canadensis Michx., Myriophyllum spicatum
L., Potamogeton natans L. and Nuphar lutea (L.)
and Chara globularis Thuil. Marsh vegetation is
more well developed and built by patches of Glyceria
maxima (Hartm.) Holmb., Phalaris arundinacea L.,
Bulboschoenus maritimus (L.), Palla Oenanthe aquatica
(L.) Poir., and Rorippa amphibia (L.) Besser. Important
components are also pioneering annual species growing
at the edge of waterside habitats, such as Polygonum
L. spp. and Bidens L. spp.; Agrostis stolonifera L.,
Ranunculus sceleratus L. and Alopecurus aequalis
Sobol.; and pleuston species, such as Lemna minor L.,
Spirodela polyrhiza (L.) Schleid., and Salvinia natans
(L.) All.
The second type of habitat where T. intricata was
found is a temporary pool with a diameter of 70-80 m
that occasionally appears (in the years with abundant
Discovering the Rare Tolypella intricata...
839
Fig. 9. Maximum Likelihood tree of the psbC gene analyses performed to confirm the discovery of T. intricata. Bootstrap analyses with
values above 50 are included. The scale bar indicate 2% divergence.
rainfall) in a water body in the agricultural landscape
[15, 16]. Such a shallow water body developed in the
Lublin region in karst depressions in arable fields.
In this case, the substrate was clay soil covering shallow
chalk rocks, and the formation of wetlands in this
place was last observed in 2013 [17]. The vegetation
found in this location was dominated by amphibious
plants – dwarf ephemeral wetland species and low
growing marsh species such as Alisma lanceolatum
With., Alisma plantago-aquatica L., Alisma gramineum
Lej., Isolepis supina (L.) R.Br., Limosella aquatica
L., Lythrum hyssopifolia L., Elatine alsinastrum L.,
Potentilla supina L., Rorippa palustris (L.) Besser,
Polygonum amphibium L., Polygonum lapathifolium
L., Callitriche verna L., L. minor, Juncus bufonius L.,
Oenanthe auqatica (L.) Poir., Veronica beccabunga L.,
Plantago intermedia Gilib., Sparganium erectum
L., and Typha angustifolia L. As mentioned earlier,
T. intricata was not recorded here but grew out of
the collected sediment in the laboratory together with
Chara globularis Thuill., Chara vulgaris L..
Present Distribution of and Threats of T. intricata
Currently, it is very difficult to unambiguously
determine the distribution of T. intricata and the species
conservation protection status in Europe [18-23]. Due
to the sporadic records of the species and its periodical
findings, almost all information concerning its
distribution in concerns historical sites and only three
840
Urbaniak J., Krawczyk R.
including both described in this paper were found in
21 century (Fig. 1). T. intricata, on the other hand, is
much more common in the USA [13, 14, 24]. This is
probably related to the biology of the species, which is
found periodically in ephemeral sites and is often not
recorded every year, as, for example, in the case of
Kotlice. In most of the red lists of protected species,
T. intricata has an endangered status [25-28] and
is considered a very rare species [29]. It must also
be remembered that the other species belonging to
the genus Tolypella are also rare [11]: T. glomerata
Leonh. 1863, T. canadensis T.Sawa 1973, T. hispanica
Nordst. ex T.F. Allen 1888, T. normaniana (Nordst.)
Nordst. 1868, T. salina Corill. 1960. Only T. nidifica
(O.F.Müller) A.Braun 1857 is a locally quite common
species found in the Baltic Sea. Fig. 1 and Table 1
show the places where T. intricata has been found
and the two described sites from Poland. It is clear that
there are not many locations. This is certainly influenced
by the biology of the species and its sporadic finding
and by the decrease in field research in recent years.
It is often assumed that the distribution of plant
species and the decline in biodiversity are influenced
by the progressive anthropopression and destruction
of habitats [19, 20, 30]. Furthermore, all known
descriptions and locations of the occurrence of this
species come from very specific sites, such as small
water reservoirs, pits, canals and in-field reservoirs.
They are, of course a subject of anthropopression,
but the distribution of T. intricata is also influenced
by a poor understanding of these specific habitats and
the knowledge that this species can be found in such
places [31-34].
This study reported the first record of T. intricata
in Poland in over 150 years and also the most recent
reliable record of the species in Europe. Results of
our study enrich our knowledge distribution and the
habitat characteristics and overall ecology of this
rare Charophyte species. Our finding significantly
contributes to the species biogeography, which is
reviewed and discussed.
Acknowledgments
This research received support from the
SYNTHESYS+ project http://www.synthesys.info/
which is financed by European Community Re-search
Infrastructure Action under the H2020 Integrating
Activities Programme, Project number 823827
(AT-TAF-TA3-1) and from the Leading Research
Groups support project from the subsidy in-creased
for the period 2020–2025 in the amount of 2% of the
subsidy referred to Art. 387 (3) of the Law of 20 July
2018 on Higher Education and Science, obtained in
2019 by Wrocław University of Environmental and Life
Sciences”
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
1. GUIRY M.D., GUIRY G.M. AlgaeBase. World-wide
electronic publication National University of Ireland
Galway, 2021. Available online: http://www.algaebase.org
(accessed on 18 September 2021).
2. URBANIAK J., GąBKA M. Polish Charophytes.
An illustrated guide to identification. Publisher:
Uniwersytet Przyrodniczy we Wrocławiu, Wrocław,
Poland, 1, 2013.
3. THIERS B. Index Herbariorum: A Global Directory
of Public Herbaria and Associated Staff. New
York Botanical Garden’s Virtual Herbarium, 2016.
Available online: http://sweetgum.nybg.org/science/ih/
4. IPNI. International Plant Names Index. Published on
the Internet. The Royal Botanic Gardens Kew Harvard
University Herbaria & Libraries and Australian National
Botanic Gardens, 2021. Available online: http://www.ipni.
org, (accessed on 18 September 2021).
5. TURLAND N.J., WIERSEMA J.H., BARRIE F.R.,
GREUTER W., HAWKSWORTH D.L., HERENDEEN
P.S., KNAPP S., KUSBER W.H., LI D.Z., MARHOLD
K., MAY T.W., MCNEILL J., MONRO A.M., PRADO
J., PRICE M.J., SMITH G.F. International Code of
Nomenclature for algae fungi and plants (Shenzhen
Code) adopted by the Nineteenth International Botanical
Congress Shenzhen China July 2017. Regnum Vegetabile
159. Publisher: Koeltz Botanical Books, Glashütten,
Germany, 2018. Available online: https://doi.org/10.12705/
Code.2018 DOI
6. KRAUSE W. Charales (Charophceae). Süsswasserflora
von Mitteleuropa. Publisher: Gustav Fisher Verlag, Jena,
Germany, 1, 1997 [In German].
7. GROFF P.A., HALE A.M., WHITLOCK B.A. Chloroplast
Lineages in Disjunct Western North American Populations
of Swertia perennis (Gentianaceae). Systematic Botany 40,
220, 2015.
8. HERACLE BIOSOFT. DNA Sequence Assembler v4.
2014. www.DnaBaser.com
9. KUMAR S., STECHER G., LI M., KNYAZ C., TAMURA
K. MEGA X: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis
across computing platforms. Molecular Biology and
Evolution, 35: 1547, 2018.
10. RAMBAUT A., DRUMMOND A.J., XIE D., BAELE G.,
SUCHARD M.A. Posterior summarisation in Bayesian
phylogenetics using Tracer 1.7. Syst. Biol. 67, 901,
2018
11. PéREZ W., HALL J.D., MCCOURT R.M., KAROL K.G.
Phylogeny of North American Tolypella (Charophyceae
Charophyta) based on plastid DNA sequences with a
description of Tolypella ramosissima sp. nov. Journal of
Phycology 50 (5), 776, 2014. doi/10.1111/jpy.12219. Epub
2014 Aug 16. PMID: 26988636.
12. LEMIEUX C., OTIS C., TURMEL M. Comparative
chloroplast genome analyses of streptophyte green
algae uncover major structural alterations in the
Klebsormidiophyceae,
Coleochaetophyceae
and
Zygnematophyceae. Frontiers in Plant Science 7, 24, 2016.
13. PéREZ W., HALL J.D., MCCOURT R.M., KAROL
K.G. Oospore dimensions and morphology in North
Discovering the Rare Tolypella intricata...
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
American Tolypella (Charophyceae Charophyta). Journal
of Phycology 51, 310, 2015. doi.org/10.1111/jpy.12275
PéREZ W., CASANOVA M.T., HALL J.D., MCCOURT
R., KAROL K.G. Phylogenetic congruence of ribosomal
operon and plastid gene sequences for the Characeae with
an emphasis on Tolypella (Characeae Charophyceae).
Phycologia 56 (2), 230, 2017. doi.org/10.2216/16-16.
BIGGS J., VON FUMETTI S., KELLY-QUINN M.
The importance of small waterbodies for biodiversity
and ecosystem services: implications for policy makers.
Hydrobiologia, 793, 39, 2017. doi.org/10.1007/s10750-0163007-0
BEKLIOğLU M., MEERHOFF M., DAVIDSON T.A.,
GER K.A., HAVENS K.E., MOSS B. Preface: shallow
lakes in a fast changing world, the 8th International
Shallow Lakes Conference. Hydrobiologia, 778, 11, 2016.
doi.org/10.1007/s10750-016-2840-5
KRAWCZYK R., CWENER A., MICHALCZUK W.,
ZUBEL R. Ephemeral wetland communities of IsoëtoNano-Juncetea class – new data from south-eastern
Poland. Biodiveristy Research and Conservation 42, 41,
2016.
ABDELAHAD N., PICCOLI F. Report on Charophytes
from rice fields in northern Italy including the alien species
Chara fibrosa ssp. benthamii. Plant Biosyst.Int. J. Deal. All
Asp. Plant Biol., 152, 603, 2018.
BLAžENčIć J. Overview of the Stoneworts (Charales) of
Serbia with the Estimation of the Threat Status. Botanica
Serbica, 38 (1), 130, 2014.
KORSCH H. The worldwide range of the Charophyte
species native to Germany. Rostock. Meeresbiol. Beitr. 1,
96, 2018.
LANGANGEN A. Charophytes (Charales) from Samos
and Ikaria (Greece) Collected in 2013 and Report on Some
Localities in Skiathos (Greece). Fl. Medit. 24, 151, 2014.
LANGANGEN A. Some finds of Charophytes from EastAfrica (Zambia, Tanzania, Kenya and Somalia). Acta
Musei Natl. Pragae Ser. B Hist. Nat. 71, 248, 2015.
ROMANOV R.E., NAPOLITANO T., VAN DEWEYER
K., TROIA A. New records and observations to the
Characean flora of Sicily (Italy). Webbia, 74, 119, 2019.
VOUILLOUD A.A., LEONARDI P.I., CáCERES E.J.
Mixed evolutionary traits of Tolypella (section Rothia,
Charales) compared with Chara and Nitella shown by
ultrastructure of vegetative internodal cells. Aquatic
Botany. 120 (A), 72, 2015.
BLAžENčIć J., STEFANOVIć B., BLAžENčIć ž.,
STEFANOVIć V. Red Data List of Charophytes in the
Balkans. Biodiversity and Conservation, 15, 3445, 2006.
doi.org/10.1007/s10531-005-2008-5
MJELDE M., SWE T., LANGANGEN A., BALLOT A.
A contribution to the knowledge of charophytes in
Myanmar; morphological and genetic identification and
ecology notes. Bot. Lett. 168, 109, 2021.
SCHUBERT H., MARQUARDT R., SCHORIES D.,
BLINDOW I. Biogeography of Chilean charophytes,
Aquatic Botany,Volume 120 (A), 141, 2015.
TRBOJEVIć I., PREDOJEVIć D. Algae in Shallow and
Small Water Bodies of Serbia: A Frame for Species and
Habitat Protection. In Small Water Bodies of the Western
Balkans, Eds. PEšIć V., MILOšEVIć, D., MILIšA, M.,
Publisher: Springer, Germany, 2022. doi.org/10.1007/9783-030-86478-1_8
841
29. WEYER K. Tolypella intricata. In Die Characeen
Deutschland, Eds. Die Arbeitsgruppe Characeen
Deutschlands Armleuchteralgen, Publisher: Springer
Verlag, Berlin – Heidelberg, Germany, 1, 2016 [In
German].
30. DEUTSCHLANDS A.C. Chapter 9: The Stonewort algae
communities in Germany. In The Characeen of Germany,
Eds. The working group Characeen Deutschlands
Characea, Publisher: Springer Verlag, Berlin – Heidelberg,
Germany, 1, 2016 [In German].
31. DUARTE T., ALMEIDA T.S., ALBERTONI E.F.,
PALMA-SILVA C. Role of the propagule bank in
reestablishing submerged macrophytes after removal
of free-floating plants for recovery of a shallow lake in
Southern Brazil. Ecol. Austral., 30, 239–250, 2020.
32. BORISOVA V. Species Diversity and Ecology of Charales
(Charophyta) of the Zone of Deciduous Forests of Ukraine.
Algologia, 27 (4), 435, 2017.
33. LAFON P., LAMBERT É. State of knowledge on
Charophytes from Aquitaine and Poitou-Charentes, for
a updated inventory. Bull. Soc. Bot. Centre-Ouest 51, 44,
2020 [In French].
34. Collective. Contributions to the inventory of the Characeae
of France of the year 2017. Bull. Soc. Bot. Centre-Ouest,
NS, 49, 41, 2018 [In French].
35. OLSEN S. Danish Charophyta. Videnskabernes Selskab
Biologiske Skrifter. Skrifter 3 (1), 1, 1944 [In Danish].
36. CORILLION R. The charophyceae of France and d.
Europe Western. Lab work. Bot. College Science.
d.Angers. Publisher: Otto Koeltz Verlag, KoenigsteinTaunus, Germany, 1, 1957 [In French].
37. MOORE J.A. Charophytes of Great Britain and Ireland.
BSBI Handbook, London, Great Britain, 1, 1986.
38. BAZZICHELLI G., ABDELAHAD N. Water algae dessert
of Italy. Analytical flora of Carophyceae; Publisher:
Sapienza University of Rome, Rome, Italy, 1, 2009 [In
Italian].
39. BRUINSMA J., KRAUSE W., NAT E., RAAM J.
Identification table for ringworts in the Benelux; Publisher:
Stichting Jeugdbon-duitgeverij, Utrecht, Netherlands, 1,
1998 [In Dutch].
40. GąBKA M. Charophytes of the Wielkopolska region (NW
Poland): distribution taxonomy and autecology. Publisher:
Bogucki Wydawnictwo Naukowe, Poznań, Poland, 1,
2009.
41. BLINDOW I. Faktablad kransalger. ArtDatabanken
Swedish threatened species unit. 2020. Available online:
http://www.dha.slu.se (acessed June 29 2022).
42. BLAžENčIć J., STANKOVIć M. Tolypella intricata
(Trent. ex Roth.) Leonhardi (Charales) – New species in
the flora Serbia. Nature protection, 60 (1-2), 215, 2008 [In
Croatian].
43. VESIć. A., BLAžENčIč. J., STANKOVIć M.
Charophytes (Charophyta) in the Zasavica. Archives of
Biological Sciences, 63 (3), 883, 2011. doi.org/10.2298/
ABS1103883V
44. STEWART N.F., CHURCH J.M. Red Data Books of
Britain and Ireland Stoneworts. Publisher: The Joint
Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough, Great
Britain, 1, 1992.